Venice Commission: Believers cannot be forced into military service

A meeting of the Venice Commission. Photo: BBC
The Venice Commission has issued an opinion stating that Ukraine cannot force individuals to carry or use weapons if they refuse military service on grounds of conscience, according to Sudebno-Yuridicheskaya Gazeta (Legal and Juridical Newspaper).
This ruling was made in response to a request from the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, which was reviewing a mobilization case involving a member of the Seventh-day Adventist Church. In a letter dated December 4, 2024, Victor Kryvenko, who was acting chairman of the Constitutional Court at the time, requested an amicus curiae opinion from the Venice Commission regarding alternative (non-military) service.
Ukrainian courts had ruled that national legislation does not provide for an alternative to military service during mobilization, and that the right to express one’s religion or beliefs is not absolute and must comply with the constitutional duty to defend the territorial integrity and sovereignty of the state against foreign aggression.
However, after analyzing international and European law, the Venice Commission concluded that conscientious objection to military service cannot be completely denied even during wartime and that under no circumstances can a conscientious objector be forced to carry or use a weapon, even for the self-defense of the country.
It is worth noting that the Supreme Court of Ukraine previously ruled that religious beliefs do not grant a person the right to defer mobilization.
Earlier, the UOJ reported that the Venice Commission had agreed to review the issue of alternative service in Ukraine.
Read also

In Ukraine, Trump’s 'spiritual advisor' reassured of religious freedom
Pastor Mark Burns stated that Ukraine, despite the war, is a "beacon of religious freedom."

Lavra brethren congratulate Metropolitan Pavel on 31 years as abbot
The monks of the Kyiv-Pechersk Lavra have expressed hope that they will soon be able to pray again with their abbot.
Amsterdam: Intrusion into Lavra Caves – a return to Soviet-era persecution
International lawyer Robert Amsterdam has condemned the actions of Ukraine’s Ministry of Culture regarding the inspection of holy relics in the Caves of the Kyiv-Pechersk Lavra, calling it a violation of religious freedom.
Over 20 EU states condemn Hungary for ban on LGBT propaganda among children
“This restricts the right to peaceful assembly and freedom of expression,” diplomats state in a joint declaration.
His Beatitude officiates consecration of Bishop of Rakhiv
At the Church of St. Agapitus in the Lavra, the Primate of the UOC ordained a vicar for the Khust Eparchy.
Met Victor: It is painful to see Lavra's relics turned into test subjects
According to the bishop, there is particular concern over how members of the scientific commission will handle the holy relics.